Linoy Joseph

vinay raj . b says:

i didnt understand yet what you meant……could u please explain what quote means…..“Absolute Theory of Zero is a new mathematical system which explains the established theories in a different light. Through the theory I’m trying to explain that the speed of light is not constant always,”

Boby John says:

Oh! proud of all Indians,
I red your news many times,I really proud of myself that Iam also from your country, India.
Wish you all the success

കാട്ടിപ്പരുത്തി says:

I come to know bt her by yur article in mathrubhumi-
we are proud of her and my prays to her

NextDoorNerd says:

Linoy, you are a geek right ?? then why shouldn’t you google about this news a little…

I couldn’t find any American Journal of Theoretical Physics or any of her published papers… this news is a pure scam,first appeared in Indian Express, now appeared in a few other papers too, some of the papers published it as a heading news… But I don’t know why these people are not looking at the credibility of the news… Seems like this news is a pure scandal…

Chi Chung says:

This looks like a media hype. There is no institute like IIMSc. Siemens Westinghouse Science and Technology competition is open only for US citizens.

There is no Dr Soumya Vasudevan who received a Hind Rattan Prize..

and ….

Hashira Fatima says:

congragulatoins my Sister, I invites You to visit our School . The place of Great Kunhali Marakkar

Mujeeb Ahmed says:

Congratulations on your great achievement…

A young indian girl leaping towards such great height is really an inspiration for the youth…

All the best wishes….
May god bless U.

Sudhi says:

I think it is a hoax.
http://pillasar.blogspot.com/

p b kaladharan says:

jai hind

siraj m.b. vattekunnam. ernakulam says:

congradulation my sister hanan. all discoveries are good.but i wish , please select and must discover who you are through soofisam.and give this almighty knowledge to the world.i hope your brain is very very excellent for this very very big chapter. ‘who you are. through soofisam only. plllllllllleeeeeeeeaswe hanan. discover this truth for me and you and world.
BY SIRAJUDHEEN QUADHIRY MOBIL NUMBER 9249550020. U MUST FIND A GOOD SOOFI GURU

Bob Matthew says:

I am really proud of you Hannan, your discoveries are stunning the world and I am positive that you are going to prove your theory to the world one of these days, and you will bring new discoveries to the ever changing world. May God bless you in all your endeavors? I would like to read more of your theories and research papers and if you are coming to Southern California would like to be present in your seminars or talks.

Sharad says:

This is very likely a hoax. I wish i could say it was an elaborate hoax, but in fact it is lazy and shoddy. As an earlier commenter pointed out, there are no independent references to this girl, no American Journal of Theoretical Physics or any other independent research.

The fact this story made it to the front page of the Deccan Chronicle speaks volumes for the editorial standards in that institution.

RIZAL says:

GREAT ACHIEVEMENT…! SO PROUD OF THIS YOUNG GIRL, MASHA ALLAH.

Sudarshan Kcherry says:

congradulation hanan i have similar theory which is beyond scientific revelation this theory is basically on the basis of experiential knowledge relativity is the only existing theory is correct but one should have the right perception always remember we are not the doer and the enjoyer the sole spirit created entire sytem so viably and spirit himself is running the show He will never reaveal complete secrete to the human folk nothing is constant but relativity is constant that is why the evolving process is happening.

wellwisher says:

proof for iimsc
http://dqindia.ciol.com/content/industrymarket/2005/105011308.asp

there may be a print mistake…it is Dr.sowmya viswanathan…not “vasudevan”…and a ladymed practinor can encourage or aid a girl who is showing great potential!!..
anyway one day or the other the full truth will comeout…so lets all wait and watch…isn’t it…

Jassim Moiden says:

Every fact put in the article is fabricated. Anyone who is even remotely knowledgeable about physics and the scientific world and community can verify easily that this girl’s ‘accomplishments’ and ”achievements’ and ‘recommendations” is fabricated.It did not appear in any legitimate and well known newsite like BBC / Reuters or popular newpaper like Hindu known for quality publishing. Most of the news for the newspaper are sourced from PTI by all newspapers.

The name of the mentor i.e. Hind Rathan award winner Dr Somya Vishwanathan is a medical doctor not a physicist and that too she is residing in US and the award Hind Rathan is awarded by the NRI crowd. See the following link.
http://www.indusbusinessjournal.com/ME2/dirmod.asp?sid=&nm=Archive&type=Publishing&mod=Publications%3A%3AArticle&mid=8F3A7027421841978F18BE895F87F791&tier=4&id=60C0FCCB079E42B1BF09681853990E7C

The physics journal that is mentioned as an esteemed journal “American Journal of Theoretical Physics” doesn’t exist as there is nothing called American Institute of Theoretical Physics and the closest is “American Journal of Physics” and an “International Journal of Theoretical Physics,” This so called institute name is not in the list of famous physics journals at http://journals.aip.org/ and has not come up in http://www.physicsforums.com .

The article in Express claims the she will participate in the Siemens Westinghouse Science and Technology competition for high school students in October this year.many Indians have participated and won this event but the catch is this event mentioned is open only for American Citizens or people residing in USA. Check their site at http://www.collegeboard.com/siemens .This is not remotely possible as this girl happens to be a 10th std girl from Kozhikode.

They claim her work has been validated by scientists at IISc and IIMSc and she visits Bangalore quite often but IIMSc is in Chennai and there is no mention of IIAP which is Indian Institute of Astrophysics whose HQ is in Bangalore. Its strange that IIAP didn’t comment as they overlook most of the candidates going for International Olympiad on Astronomy and Astrophysics.

There is nothing like Nasa “Space School Graduate” like the photograph shows a certificate with a title “”Space School Graduate” without the famous NASA blue logo. Check the Nasa site if you can find any.

There is no sign or mention about this in any other reputed Science Journals or Magazines and no one has published about her theory yet .Doing a simple google search .

There is no mention or any proof of appreciation by APJ Abdul Kalam or Obama or any other members of the scientific community mentioned anywhere apart from that article since a similar prodigy named Tathagath Avatar Tulsi who made waves in the physics some world years ago. He was quoted by BBC,Time Magazine, TOI…etc. Run a google search on him and see the real prodigy

Muhammed Najeeb says:

Yes its u can prove the velocity of light will b different at different time…congrats….as Quran says , Prophet Mohammed had done his Miuraj with differnt velocities as God created him from his Noor(light)…So keep exploring …

bingo says:

UR ALL IDIOTS TO THINK THIS IS REAL

Kuma says:

About Miss Hannan Binth Hashim and her credulous press reporters Ms Anula Aboobacker and Ms Cissy Jacob who conveniently refuse to answer criticisms, I’d say:
1. As already pointed out, the “Space School Graduate” is not a degree. Nasa Space center at Houston is an organization to promote interest in space study among youngsters. The degree they give is only informal. Anyone ready to participate in their activities for a few days may get it. The Space Center have rocket modeler software with which one can design a model and launch it provided one is willing to pay money. These things are nothing extraordinary. Definitely Miss Hannan’s parents must have known it.
2. Reports mention several “mentors” of Miss Hannan. One of them is Prof. Jayanth Murthy of Indian Institute of Science. Prof. Murthy admits that Miss Hannan has visited IIA library but clarifies that he hasn’t had any scientific discussion with her. The relevant part of his message is quoted from Mr. Aniver Aravind (Blog “Chithrakaran”):
“Thanks for forwarding this link to me. I will also post my comment in that site itself. This girl came to see me some months ago and told me that she had this theory that Einstein was wrong and that Kalam was impressed by her theory… Read more. She also had a write-up in the Indian Express (if I remember right). I told her that the press and Presidents were easily impressed but that ground breaking theories do not come from school kids – they just don’t have the mathematics and physics tools necessary. I advised her to continue her interest in science but that she should work hard to learn everything necessary and that I would be glad to help her where possible. That is the limit of my contact with her (other than one more brief visit and email exchange). This is what I do for any student who contacts me and have done for dozens of students.

I am not her mentor and have no knowledge of her work. If anyone were to ask me, I would say that I do not believe in her “theory” but am happy to see her so interested in science. After this latest episode, I am much less forgiving and would believe that her story is a tissue of lies from beginning to end.

Again, thanks … Read more for this link. Someone had forward the Malayalam paper where it first appeared and I had written to them as well as this girl but this site gives me the chance to make it public.”
This reply is self explanatory.
3. Another mentor mentioned is one Dr. Sowmya Vasudevan who is a Hind Rattan award winner. But there is no such name on the list of Hind Rattan Award winners. When this inconsistency was pointed out someone replied that there was one with that name who got the award in 2005. This is not true. In 2005 one Dr. Sowmya Viswanathan (medicine) got the award but not Dr. Sowmya Vasudevan. This slight alteration in the detail might have been made deliberately to thwart verification.
3. Miss Hannan claims that she has formulated a novel theory called “Absolute Theory of Zero” and that her paper on the theory is going to be published in a journal by name “American Journal of Theoretical Physics.” The fragments of the “theory” as these are given by the reporters are nothing short of silly nonsense. Apart from this, there is an “International Journal of Theoretical Physics” and an “American Journal of Physics” but no such thing as “American Journal of Theoretical Physics” to carry the kid’s paper. When Unnikrishnan pointed out this inconsistency Ms. Ms. Anula replied that there is an “American Journal of Physics” which started publication in 1940. She doesn’t realize that her “American Journal of Physics” is not the same as the “American Journal of Theoretical Physics” of the reports!
Apparently, the Expressbuzz reporter Ms Anula Aboobacker (19 June 2009) and Mathrubhumi reporter Ms Cissy Jacob (14 June 2009) do not seem to have sought any documentary evidence from the kid. They relied upon Miss Hannan’s words instead of asking her to produce the letter of acceptance Miss Hannan “got” from the so called “American Journal of Theoretical Physics.” Instead, they simply believed the words of a school kid, and her mother. Even after adverse remarks were aired, these reporters did not come up with any documentary evidence to absolve Miss Hannan. Nor had Miss Hannan herself, nor her mother, nor her Principal given any documentary evidence. Seeing the same article on Miss Hannan reproduced in several sites, one of her innocent supporters asserts that the news must be true since it is found everywhere on the net! He doesn’t realize that he is reading the same news reproduced in different sites. It’s astonishing to find naïve persons complaining that Miss. Hannan is being criticized unfairly.
4. Miss Hannan claims that she got special permission to participate in the project-based “Siemens Westinghouse Science and Technology Competition” in which only US students are allowed to take part. In this matter also the reporters haven’t cited any document supporting Miss Hannan’s claim. However, I’ve contacted the Seimens people for verification of the matter and am waiting for their reply.
5. Another claim is that Miss Hannan is joining MIT. How can a 10th standard kid without qualifying SAT and IELT even apply for admission to MIT? Have the reporters verified whether she has qualified these tests or not? Or has the MIT too exempted Miss Hannan from qualifying SAT and IELT? If they had, is there any evidence to the effect?
To sum up: Miss Hannan is either a fraud or a highly imaginative kid who has mistaken her fantasy for reality. Please don’t spoil the kid by dancing to her tunes. Save her from her fantasies and guide her along the right path towards the study of science. Miss Hannan must come to terms with reality. She may grow out of her fantasy to become a great scientist, of course not right now, but later, much later, it may take years! I wish the poor girl a bright future.
I request her reporters Ms Anula Aboobacker and Ms Cissy Jacob either to defend their reports or to tend a public apology in the matter.

SUMITHRAN OM says:

Hai………

She is my “GURU”

Narhtimus

Jayan says:

I think this article is totally RUBBISH and FAKE. I am a scientist. I know how scientific articles are published. If she is “real” then her articles should be published in reputed journals. I searched in google for her but i couldn’t get any real news about her other than these “stories”

Nelson says:

realty is Albert Einstein didnt pass high school so he cant get into any universities also he was poor in math during his school years. he was a prof in Prinston University without a Doctroal Digree

Kuma1 says:

Nelson is right fact is Albert Einstein didn’t pass high school so he can’t get into any universities also he was poor in math during his school years. When he formulate his famous equation even without a high school diploma He just need a paper and pencil don’t need any sophisticated labs like in IISC or IIT. stupid Indian fat ass slum dogs like (Prof. Jayanth Murthy )don’t know what is talent is!!

bikash says:

@NELSON AND KUMA1

”realty is Albert Einstein didnt pass high school so he cant get into any universities also he was poor in math during his school years. he was a prof in Prinston University without a Doctroal Digree”

i think u donno much about einstein’s history..d u??
he was a science & maths prodigy right from his childhood days(HIS TUTOR WAS PAULI,a famous physicist who had given pauli’s exclusion theory)…but he was neva interested in other subject so he did’nt finished his high skool and he had to leave his skool too since they were just not acceptable to his new radical ideas and thought he was a dumb boy and they hates jews too..therefore he applied for zurich polytechnic(a famous university)which admits students even without their school certificates but herein lies the toughest task..the exam was tough(especially in maths and science) which means even if u hav no high skool certificates and u pass da exam u r considered good enough to d ur undergraduate degree course..here too he cleared the exam in those two subjects but flopped in other subjects(thus failed in 1st attempt)..he tried again in the 2nd year and excelled again in maths and science but flopped in other subject…but the univ headmester (prof. RUTHERFORD) checked his maths and physics and was too much impressed with dat and gave him admission in undergraduate degree of physics and later he had done his PhD too from dat university…THUS EINSTEIN FORMULATED HIS FAMOUS THEORY OF RELATIVITY AND FOUR OTHER WELL KNOWN RESEARCH PAPERS(IN PHOTOELECTRIC EFFECT,BROWNIAN MOVEMENT ETC) AFTER GETTING HIS BASIC KNOWLEDGE IN MATHS AND PHYSICS….MANY PPL HERE SEEMS DEVOID OF ANY LOGICAL REASONING AND PRAISING HANAN WITHOUT EVEN KNOWING THAT NO PAPERS OF HER HAS BEEN PUBLISHED IN ANY JOURNAL TILL DATE….she is talkin about proving einstein theory wrong..if thats the case she would hav been famous like einstein becomes when he published his papers and got an instant recognition 4 his theory overnight…nowhere her research paper were published….u still donno wats da place of relativity in the realms of physics….to prove it wrong will create an instant reaction among physicists around da world…..first let her pass her high school then talk about higher physics….

sandoZ says:

I believe she had been a great mathematician of the calibre of Einstein and Newton in her previous incarnation. i wish all success in her field astronomy.